Five years after George Floyd protests, police reform slows amid Bay Area political shifts

The police killing of George Floyd five years ago was miles away in Minneapolis but the Bay Area heavily felt its influence where simmering frustration over police violence spilled out into the streets in cities like San Jose and Oakland National media shone an unexpected and harsh spotlight on San Jose aided by viral video clips of violent police crowd control measures depicting officers battering protesters with bean bags hard foam rounds and tear gas that had city leaders denouncing the tactics and pledging swift improvement Across the country the seeds of a national reckoning on police use of force were planted But the activists and locality and civic leaders who sought to capitalize on the moment say what sprouted has been uneven at best Perhaps the bulk telling just this past week the U S Department of Justice sought to terminate federal consent decrees aimed at police revision in cities including Minneapolis where former police officer Derek Chauvin was convicted of murder after pressing his knee onto a prone Floyd s neck on May while arresting him for an accusation of using a counterfeit bill Chauvin is right now serving a -year prison sentence Oakland for instance reduced police funding increases for a year after the protests And while the city initially pumped an extra million into the city s Department of Violence Prevention an agency that works to address the social drivers of violence in the public its funding has been slashed amid a deep budget problem Jackie Byers who helped lead the Black Organizing Project in its bid to abolish the Oakland Unified School District s police department in the wake of the protests is unbowed by the slowing political momentum for police transformation When you have these wins you shift things you re going to have a reaction from the forces that gained from people being afraid Byers announced If we understand history then we understand that whenever we have these wins there s inevitably going to be these forces that try to push back on these things We can t expect that the institutions that have benefited from people being marginalized or oppressed are going to without pressure continue to keep up the good work Policies that sprang from or were energized by the summer of have provided several markers of lasting effects including broader reforms such as a state ban on police chokeholds laws to decertify trouble officers and expand citizens access to disciplinary records and rule to limit the use of munitions to quell protests In Oakland the city s Reimagining General Safety Task Force recommended dozens of procedures the city could improve policing and while countless were never enacted it did lead to the creation of MACRO a venture aimed at reducing police calls for those experiencing mental wellness crises There absolutely was a backlash disclosed Alameda County Supervisor Nikki Fortunato Bas a former Oakland City Council president and co-chair of the task force And with the backlash it did impact the momentum that we had At the same time we saw real gains A similar task force formed in San Jose but plenty of of its members resigned in its infancy to make a point to the city after asserting the group was created as political cover rather than a genuine catalyst for sorely needed reforms brought to the national forefront by Floyd s death There has been a lot of two procedures forward three initiatives back I personally have never thought that the administration was going to do it with all of its humanity and all of its flaws It was never going to get the thing done for us It was never going to bring us to true safety reported Derrick Sanderlin a San Jose activist who was seriously injured by police during the first day of the city s protests Derrick Sanderlin near the location where he was shot in the groin with a foam round by a San Jose police officer five years ago during the May th George Floyd protest in downtown San Jose Calif on Friday May Dai Sugano Bay Area News Group I think that was kind of the vibe that people got when they were out on the street is that no one was coming except for us Sanderlin stated I think that feeling is still the same Raj Jayadev co-founder of the South Bay civil rights group Silicon Valley De-Bug announced those truly seeking reforms were never hinging their hopes on a regime savior I think the lesson is don t give the power of a ground-up movement to a political class that didn t deserve it to begin with he noted The racial justice people were marching for on the streets that s not going to be where that vision of racial justice is going to come from Sanderlin s injury reflects a few of the majority notable fallout from the protests through the litany of lawsuits filed against police and city governments for serious injuries from officers who in a great number of cases were admittedly minimally trained in the less-lethal gun launchers they were deployed to use Even at demonstrations in suburban Walnut Creek police were criticized for a response marred the greater part visibly by officers siccing dogs on protesters One man was merely watching the protests in downtown San Jose when he lost his eye to one of the police projectiles Sanderlin who once helped conduct bias training for new police officers in recent months reached a legal settlement with the city after he was shot with a projectile in the groin by an officer while trying to calm tensions between a crowd and a police line Derrick Sanderlin right during a protest against the killing of George Floyd in San Jose Sanderlin who once helped conduct bias training for new police officers not long ago reached a legal settlement with the city after he was shot with a projectile in the groin by an officer while trying to calm tensions between a crowd and a police line Photo by Kyle Martin All informed San Jose is expected to pay at least million in settlements or verdict rewards stemming from protest lawsuits The San Jose Police Department declined to comment for this story citing the litigation It s not going to take away all of the feelings I had from the street to the hospital bed but it has taught me that they can say what they like but we hold their feet to the fire Sanderlin commented of police I hope that our settlement I hope at least part of it can be the planting of several seeds of something new that will continue to push the city to act right because we just know they won t In Oakland Tosh Sears was injured during the protests when he was hit by a rubber police bullet as he turned to leave when Alameda County sheriff s deputies and Oakland police officers began using tear gas to disperse the crowd He and another demonstrator shared a settlement with Oakland and the county which secured numerous reforms from both agencies in how they handle future protesters after accusing sheriff s deputies of using tactics in Oakland that the city s police force was banned from employing including the use of rubber bullets SAN JOSE CALIFORNIA - MAY A protester is detained by San Jose Police officers at a protest of the killing of George Floyd outside of San Jose City Hall in downtown San Jose Calif on Sunday May Nhat V Meyer Bay Area News Group Anthony Jay of Oakland shows marks from non-lethal weapons shot by police who used flash-bang grenades and tear gas to disperse the crowd on Broadway near the Oakland Police Department during the fourth day of protests over George Floyd's death by the Minneapolis police in Oakland Calif on Monday June Ray Chavez Bay Area News Group OAKLAND CA - MAY The Wells Fargo Bank is set afire during a demonstration in advocacy of George Floyd in Oakland Calif on Friday May The protest was held to denounce the police killing of Floyd an African-American man killed by police in Minneapolis Doug Duran Bay Area News Group WALNUT CREEK CA - JUNE Protesters march on North Main St as a Walnut Creek Police officer observes from atop of a Humvee during a Black Lives Matter protest in Walnut Creek Calif on Monday June Walnut Creek Police issued a curfew tonight after looters descending into downtown and looted local businesses the preceding day Over police officers from agencies around the county are in Walnut Creek patrolling the area Jose Carlos Fajardo Bay Area News Group May San Jose Calif Several arrests were made after San Jose Police officers clashed with protesters who marched through San Jose on Friday to protest the police brutality that killed George Floyd in Minneapolis Minn on Monday During the march protesters were confronted by police who declared the protest unlawful and began to push protesters down Santa Clara Street back towards San Jose City Hall from U S Highway Photo by Kyle MartinSan Jose Police officers clashed with protesters who marched through San Jose to protest the police brutality that killed George Floyd Photo by Kyle Martin SAN JOSE CALIFORNIA - MAY A protester uses water after getting tear gassed during a protest regarding the killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis in downtown San Jose Calif on Friday May Nhat V Meyer Bay Area News Group WALNUT CREEK CA - JUNE A protester reacts after a flash bang explodes near her after blocking the I- north bound freeway during a Black Lives Matter protest in Walnut Creek Calif on Monday June Walnut Creek Police issued a curfew tonight after looters descending into downtown and looted local businesses the previous 24 hours Over police officers from agencies around the county are in Walnut Creek patrolling the area Jose Carlos Fajardo Bay Area News Group Show Caption of SAN JOSE CALIFORNIA - MAY A protester is detained by San Jose Police officers at a protest of the killing of George Floyd outside of San Jose City Hall in downtown San Jose Calif on Sunday May Nhat V Meyer Bay Area News Group Expand Nowadays Sears sees the churn at the top of Oakland police force as an ongoing concern We don t see modification we don t see nothing worse but we just see more of police doing nothing Sears reported I don t see any kind of progress Rachel Lederman senior counsel with the Partnership for Civil Justice Fund who has litigated several lawsuits borne from the Bay Area protests lauded the impact that lawsuit settlements injunctions and trial verdicts across the country have had on restricting how aggressively police can act against demonstrators But she lamented a legislative carve-out in California that allows munitions and tear gas to still be used when it s objectively reasonable to protect people from death or serious bodily injury That s open to interpretation and can be the exception that swallows the rule she declared Walter Wilson a longtime South Bay locality leader led the mass resignation from San Jose s post-Floyd constituents safety task force which later reconvened The protests helped galvanize political leadership to patronage more Black locality stake he announced pointing to the community dollars committed to the Silicon Valley African American Cultural Center a major housing area arts and social services hub set to open in in San Jose Wilson serves as project director Related Articles Driver arrested in Castro Valley roadway shooting San Diego plane crash is a devastating loss to the alternative rock music population Inspirational inmate finds his freedom day Trucking school identified granted early parole from San Quentin Arson suspected as power outage in southeast France disrupts final day of Cannes Film Festival Santa Cruz wharf collapse Plans take shape for rebuilding as summer beach season begins It s an example he revealed of leaders navigating a political weather where public-facing diversity efforts have come under federal scrutiny What they re saying almost to a person is we can take this stuff off but that s not going to stop us from conducting ourselves in the way we know which is right which is making sure we are inclusive and we have diversity Wilson declared We don t need to say it to do it Jayadev is paying particular attention to younger generations and how the scars they gained will help them take the torch of political activism You would see people downtown young people downtown grabbing a megaphone or standing on top of that rock at City Hall and think wow am I looking at that generation and those people that are going to be leaders that not just get activated but are going to lead us to this new place that we only dreamed about